The thing is, the comm is run by one of the most strident Anti-Rosefen members.

I like Rose just fine, thanks.

So Rose & Rosefen bashing is acceptable and not at all punished or even frowned upon.

That's not true, I don't allow any bashing. If there are icons bashing Rose then I delete the posts. I'm behind at the moment as I'm busy in RL, but if there have been any such posts in the past couple of days, I'd appreciate a link so I could remove them.